Skip to main content

The Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA) stands as a landmark piece of legislation for employee benefits and financial security. Its provisions have a profound impact on the lives of millions of American workers, retirees, and employers.

It’s more than just a legal framework: ERISA ensures that employee benefit plans—whether related to retirement, healthcare, or disability—are administered fairly, transparently, and in the best interests of plan participants and beneficiaries. Governing fiduciary responsibilities and grievance processes, ERISA impacts how employees interact with their benefit plans on a fundamental level.

In the following sections, we'll explore the core components of ERISA and its impact on both employees and employers.

ERISA: An Overview

As mentioned, ERISA serves as a framework governing various aspects of employee benefit programs in the United States. This comprehensive legislation establishes stringent standards for an array of crucial benefits, including retirement accounts, healthcare plans, and disability coverage. The act’s primary objectives are to safeguard the rights of individuals participating in these plans and to secure the assets accrued within them.

ERISA lawyer helping client understand provisions

Originally enacted in 1974, ERISA emerged as a response to the need for enhanced protection and transparency for plan beneficiaries. Through its provisions, ERISA regulates employer-sponsored benefits, assuring that employees receive fair treatment, comprehensive information, and the security they deserve.

The History and Origins of ERISA

As with much consumer protection legislation, ERISA’s origins go farther back than the bill’s signing in 1974. It came about after a substantial push from the American public.

In 1963, the Studebaker-Packer Corporation shut down an auto manufacturing plant in South Bend, Indiana. Upon its closure, the pension plan did not have enough assets to provide the coverage promised to its employees. This closure served as a catalyst of the pension reform movement—ultimately resulting in ERISA; the United Auto Workers (UAW) union used the shutdown as an opportunity to put default risk and termination insurance on the legislative agenda. However, it took another decade before President Gerald Ford signed ERISA into law—thanks to insistent work on the part of pension reform advocates.

Now, different aspects of ERISA are under management by three oversight entities: the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), the US Labor Department, and the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation. Together, they collectively ensure the protection and regulation of employee benefit programs.

What Are ERISA’s Main Objectives?

At its core, ERISA aims to safeguard the interests of employee benefit plan participants and beneficiaries, setting minimum standards for various aspects of employee benefit plans. These standards ensure fairness, transparency, and protection for those enrolled in such programs.

Let’s dive deeper into some of the specific ways ERISA protects your employer-sponsored benefits.

Information Transparency

The legislation compels plan administrators to provide comprehensive information to participants regarding the terms and conditions of their benefit plans. This includes details about plan features, funding mechanisms, and eligibility criteria. Moreover, by requiring transparent and accessible plan information, ERISA empowers individuals to make informed decisions about their retirement, healthcare, disability coverage, and other benefits.

Participation Rights

Guaranteeing eligible employees the right to participate in employer-sponsored benefit plans, ERISA prevents arbitrary exclusions or discrimination in plan enrollment. In doing so, the legislation promotes equal access to these essential programs for all eligible employees.

Vesting and Benefit Accrual

ERISA ensures that employees' accrued benefits under defined benefit pension plans become non-forfeitable after a specified period. Commonly referred to as vesting, this prevents the loss of earned retirement benefits due to job changes, plan amendments, or, plan terminations.

Funding Requirements

The legislation’s text establishes funding rules to ensure that defined benefit pension plans have sufficient assets to meet their obligations to participants. This helps mitigate the risk of underfunded plans that could jeopardize beneficiaries' retirement security.

Fiduciary Responsibilities

ERISA imposes stringent fiduciary duties on plan administrators and those responsible for managing plan assets. Fiduciaries must act in the best interests of plan participants and beneficiaries, managing plan assets prudently and with care. ERISA holds fiduciaries accountable for any breaches of these duties, ensuring that beneficiaries' interests are protected.

Grievance and Appeals Process

ERISA mandates the establishment of fair and accessible procedures for plan participants and beneficiaries to address disputes or denied claims. These grievance and appeal processes provide individuals with a means to challenge benefit determinations they believe to be incorrect or unfair. By offering an avenue for recourse, ERISA enhances the overall fairness and accountability of employee benefit plans.

ERISA creates a comprehensive regulatory framework that safeguards the rights and interests of those covered by employee benefit plans. Under ERISA, individuals receive the benefits they have earned while holding plan administrators accountable for their fiduciary duties. Additionally, it gives employees an avenue to file appeals if they feel a claim has been unjustly denied.

Significant Amendments to ERISA

Over the years, many amendments have been added to the legislative text to expand employee protections. Let’s unpack several of the more significant additions:

Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA)

The Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA) was enacted in 1985, ensuring that employees terminated from their jobs can keep their healthcare coverage for a certain period of time. However, it does not protect those who voluntarily resign or are let go for “gross misconduct.”

COBRA coverage begins on the first day of termination and lasts for 18 months for the employee.

Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)

ERISA was amended again in 1996 with The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). HIPAA adds further security for employees’ healthcare coverage by ensuring that policyholders’ information stays private and secure.

Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA)

The Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA) was enacted in 2008. It ensures that access to mental health care has similar limitations (deductibles and co-pays) to other medical benefits. MHPAEA doesn’t require plans to offer mental health benefits.

Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA)

Enacted in 2010, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA)—still often colloquially known as Obamacare—mandated that certain large employers provide health insurance coverage to their employees or face penalties. Additionally, the ACA introduced essential health benefit requirements, banned lifetime and annual limits on essential benefits, and eliminated denial of coverage for preexisting conditions. It also established health insurance marketplaces. These actions enhanced the comprehensiveness and accessibility of healthcare plans under ERISA regulations.

Say you were being treated for a health issue for over six months before receiving health insurance. The ACA protects you from any pre-existing condition exclusions.
ERISA lawyer discussing main benefits of law

Core Provisions of ERISA

Based on ERISA’s main objectives, the text of the legislation shapes certain fundamental provisions to regulate and protect various types of employee benefit plans, including retirement, healthcare, and long-term disability plans. These core provisions establish frameworks for plan administration, fiduciary responsibilities, participant rights, and accountability.

ERISA lawyer talking about its core provisions

Below, we delve into the central tenets of ERISA and how they apply to different benefit plans. We also highlight key exemptions and exclusions.

ERISA Standards Around Fiduciary Responsibility

ERISA places significant emphasis on the fiduciary duties of all plan administrators, including those overseeing long-term disability plans.

This obligates fiduciaries to act exclusively in the best interests of plan participants and beneficiaries.

A key aspect of their role is exercising prudence and diligence when managing plan operations, investments, and benefits to safeguard participants' financial well-being.

Furthermore, fiduciaries must consistently adhere to federal law to guarantee that participants receive benefits that meet regulatory requirements. They must diligently avoid conflicts of interest—including prohibited transactions and self-dealing—and remain committed to the best interests of plan beneficiaries.

Access to Plan Information

Under ERISA, participants must have unfettered access to information pertaining to their benefit plans, including long-term disability coverage. This encompassing provision ensures that participants are not left in the dark when it comes to understanding their plans.

Plan participants need access to details about the plan's features, funding mechanisms, eligibility criteria, and the precise procedures for filing and processing claims to navigate the complexities of their plans confidently. Moreover, ERISA's commitment to information accessibility plays a pivotal role in equipping participants with the tools to secure their financial futures.

Remedies for Breach Remedies for Breach of Plan Terms and Fiduciary Duty

ERISA is not just a regulatory framework. It also protects participants' rights to seek legal recourse in cases of breaches by plan administrators. This legal avenue serves as a crucial safety net, ensuring participants can act in the face of fiduciary misconduct.

Participants can always seek remedies to get the long-term disability coverage they deserve to rectify any harm resulting from ERISA breaches.

By offering this avenue for redress, ERISA reinforces the accountability of plan administrators, bolstering the confidence of participants in the integrity of their benefit plans and the fiduciaries entrusted with their management.

ERISA Exemptions

While ERISA broadly covers private-sector employee benefit plans, certain exceptions and exemptions exist. Employee benefit plans managed by the government (federal, state, or local) are generally exempt from ERISA protections. Often, other regulatory frameworks oversee benefits for government employers. Additionally, plans established and maintained by religious organizations for their employees may also be exempt from ERISA coverage.

understanding the impact of ERISA on employees

Impact of ERISA on Employees

The impact of ERISA’s objectives and protections primarily falls on employees and their employers. As a recipient of employer-sponsored benefits, here are some ways ERISA impacts you.

  • Plan Information: ERISA ensures that employees have access to essential plan information. This transparency equips them with the knowledge needed to make informed decisions about benefits.
  • Participation and Vesting: ERISA guarantees employees the right to participate in plans without facing arbitrary exclusions or discrimination. It also ensures that accrued benefits in retirement plans become non-forfeitable over time, providing financial security.
  • Benefit Accrual and Funding: ERISA's rules on benefit accrual and plan funding mitigate the risk of underfunded plans. As a result, employees receive the benefits they've earned under their long-term disability, healthcare, and retirement plans.

What a Breach of Fiduciary Duty Means to You

In addition to those foundational impacts, ERISA provides a path to take action if your benefits aren’t fulfilled. In fact, one of ERISA's most critical impacts lies in its enforcement of fiduciary responsibilities. This protection is particularly vital in long-term disability plans, where financial well-being in times of need hinges on fiduciary diligence.

In long-term disability cases, health intertwines with financial stability. Employees can take action when they suspect their fiduciaries have strayed from their obligations. ERISA's emphasis on this aspect ensures that employees can hold those entrusted with their well-being accountable.

Employees can rest assured that those managing their benefit plans are legally obligated to act in their best interests, oversee plans with prudence, and avoid conflicts of interest.

The Grievance and Appeals Process

The grievance and appeals process is a vital component of ERISA, designed to uphold the rights and interests of employees in their benefit plans. It empowers employees to challenge decisions that could significantly impact their financial security and well-being, ensuring that they are not left without recourse when their benefits are at stake.

employee appealing his ERISA rights

Submitting a Claim

The process begins when an employee, a participant, or a beneficiary submits a formal claim for benefits to the plan administrator or designated fiduciary responsible for handling such matters. This first step allows employees to ask for the benefits they seek. Health insurance claims are often submitted by the provider for the employee.

The plan administrator must then conduct a thorough review of the claims. During this phase, the administrator must carefully consider all relevant facts, plan documents, and applicable law.

Filing an Appeal or Request for Review

If the initial claim for benefits is denied or not resolved to the employee's satisfaction, ERISA allows employees to then file an appeal, otherwise known as a request for review. Employees have the right to request a review of the decision by the plan's fiduciary responsible for appeals. Also, this offers employees the opportunity to present additional evidence or arguments to support their case and dispute the reason for denial.

Following review, the plan administrator must provide a written response explaining the decision reached and the rationale behind it. This response typically includes instructions for further action, such as pursuing another appeal if the employee remains dissatisfied.

This is a crucial stage in the process, as it can lead to the reversal of a denied claim or an equitable resolution.

When All Else Fails—Take Legal Action

If all else fails, ERISA allows employees to take their cases to court. They may file a lawsuit challenging the plan administrator’s decisions, particularly if they believe fiduciary responsibilities have been breached.

Note that a lawsuit can only make use of the information provided in your appeals. This means crafting an airtight appeal with an experienced ERISA attorney from the get-go is essential.

Impact of ERISA on Employers

ERISA also places significant responsibilities on employers who sponsor employee benefit plans. Employers have a crucial role in ensuring compliance with ERISA regulations to protect the rights and interests of plan participants and beneficiaries. As an employee, it’s important to know what your employer is responsible for so you can hold them accountable for sufficient management of your benefits.

  • Plan Establishment and Administration: Employers are responsible for establishing and maintaining employee benefit plans, whether they be retirement, health, or disability plans. This includes setting the terms and conditions of plans and ensuring they comply with ERISA standards.
  • Fiduciary Duties: Employers or designated fiduciaries must act prudently and solely in the best interests of plan participants and beneficiaries when managing plan assets and operations. As overviewed above, fiduciaries must avoid conflicts of interest and ensure that plan funds are used exclusively for the benefit of participants.
  • Plan Document and Reporting: Employers must provide participants with comprehensive plan documents that outline the plan's features, funding, eligibility criteria, and claims procedures. They also must submit annual reports to the government, maintaining transparency and accountability.
  • Funding and Contributions: For defined benefit plans, employers are responsible for ensuring that sufficient funds are available to meet the plan's obligations. They must make regular contributions to fund these plans, assuring that benefits are adequately funded.
  • Compliance and Reporting: Employers must adhere to ERISA's stringent reporting and disclosure requirements, ensuring that participants receive accurate and timely information about their benefits.

Failure to meet these responsibilities can lead to legal and financial consequences for employers, making ERISA compliance a critical aspect of managing employee benefit plans.

Work with Experienced Attorneys in Your ERISA Case

As you begin to unpack ERISA, its significance in protecting the financial security of millions of workers quickly becomes clear. From enforcing fiduciary responsibilities and empowering employees with a clearly-defined appeal process, ERISA has left an indelible mark on the world of employee benefit plans.

That said, the legislation is quite intricate—meaning that, when navigating your claim, having a legal expert well-versed in ERISA at your side is paramount. Choosing the right attorney can make all the difference in navigating this complex legal terrain.

At Kantor and Kantor, we stand ready to provide guidance, expertise, and unwavering support in your ERISA claim journey. Our team of experienced attorneys knows the nuances of ERISA law, and we are dedicated to helping you secure the benefits you rightfully deserve.

Contact Kantor and Kantor for a consultation today.