When an insurance company denies a long-term disability claim, the letter tends to arrive at the worst possible moment. The illness or injury has already made work difficult, if not impossible. The bills continue to arrive on schedule. You believed the coverage would be there for your family if you could not work, and the company that collected your premiums for years has now told you no.
At Kantor & Kantor LLP, our long-term disability lawyers represent policyholders, never insurance companies. If your claim has been denied, we can review the policy and the denial letter with you and explain your options in plain language.
Call us today at 818-886-2525 for a free consultation.
Was your long-term disability claim denied? Contact Kantor & Kantor, LLP online or call us at 818-886-2525 for a free consultation.
Do You Need a Long-Term Disability Lawyer?
A long-term disability lawyer helps you appeal or sue an insurance company that has denied or terminated your long-term disability benefits under an employer plan or a private policy.
In practice, that work usually involves the following:
- Reading the denial: identifying every reason the insurer gave and every policy provision it relied on.
- Finding the deadline: confirming how long you have to appeal or to file suit, and what happens if that date passes.
- Building the record: gathering the medical, vocational, and occupational evidence that answers the insurer’s stated reasons.
- Handling the insurer: taking over records requests, correspondence, and the appeal itself.
- Filing suit: bringing the case to court when the appeal does not resolve it.
Which of these matters most depends on whether your plan is governed by federal law or by state law. That question is worth answering before you submit anything to the insurer.
What Is Long-Term Disability Insurance?
Employers want their workers to be healthy and able to do their jobs. At the same time, an employer does not want a sick or injured worker to stay on the job unable to perform, or to leave with no income at all.
Long-term disability coverage is the usual answer. Employers purchase group policies for their employees, or make the coverage available for employees to buy.
These policies typically pay 60 to 65 percent of an insured’s working income once a disability has lasted beyond a waiting period, often 90 days. If the employee remains too ill or injured to work, benefits may continue until normal retirement age. Short-term coverage fills the gap before that point, and it is worth understanding how LTD differs from short-term disability coverage before you file.
If the policy is an individual one, state law applies, including the California Insurance Code. If an employer acquired the policy to fund an employee benefit plan, the federal Employee Retirement Income Security Act, known as ERISA, generally governs the claim instead.
Why Long-Term Disability Claims Are Denied
Insurance companies collect premiums for years and then reject valid claims on grounds that do not hold up. A denial letter can sound final while resting on a narrow reading of the policy or an incomplete picture of how the illness or injury actually affects the ability to work.
Common reasons given for a denial include the following:
- Insufficient medical evidence: The insurer says the records do not document the limitations the policy requires.
- Timing of testing: An objective test, such as an MRI, was not obtained until months after the employee stopped working, and the insurer argues it cannot show what was true on the last day worked.
- Definition of disability: The insurer may define the occupation differently, arguing that even if you cannot perform the job you actually hold, you could still perform another version of that occupation.
- Surveillance and file review: A physician who has never examined the claimant reviews the paper file and reaches a different conclusion from the treating doctors.
- Policy limitations: The insurer applies a limitation on conditions, such as mental health or self-reported symptoms, to cut benefits off after a set period.
Patterns repeat from one carrier to the next, which is why it helps to review denials by specific insurance companies when deciding how to respond. Unum is one of the most frequent LTD denial insurers.
When ERISA Governs Your Claim
ERISA was written to safeguard employee pension benefits. It was not written to regulate the insurance industry, which had been the work of the state courts. Decades ago, the United States Supreme Court held that employee benefits such as health, life, and disability coverage fall under federal law.
The practical effect is a set of rules that favors the insurer. ERISA provides limited remedies, so a group disability carrier faces far less exposure for denying a claim than it would under state law. Many claimants also make avoidable mistakes early in the process, and those mistakes can follow the claim all the way to court.
In ERISA cases, a court usually reviews the insurer’s decision without giving the insurer the benefit of the doubt. However, some plans give the insurer more authority to decide whether a claim qualifies for benefits. Several states have restricted insurers from writing that discretion into their policies.
California is among them, and Insurance Code section 10110.6 renders a discretionary clause void in a policy that provides disability coverage to a California resident.
How to Appeal a Long-Term Disability Denial
Under ERISA, the appeal is not optional in any practical sense. Federal law requires the plan to give you an opportunity to appeal and to submit additional evidence. If you do not appeal, you will likely be barred from filing suit at all.
Equally important, what you put in front of the insurer during the appeal will generally form the record a judge reviews later. Material submitted after the administrative appeal closes is generally excluded. Insurers are not required to volunteer how much is riding on that one submission.
The steps that matter most are these:
- Read the denial letter closely: Note every reason given and every document the insurer says it reviewed.
- Confirm the deadline: Claims filed in recent decades carry at least 180 days to appeal, but the period depends on when the claim was submitted.
- Request the claim file: Ask in writing for the policy, the plan documents, and the insurer’s complete file.
- Gather the evidence early: Records often come from treating physicians, and those offices can take weeks to respond.
- Answer the stated reasons: The appeal should address the specific policy language the insurer relied on, not simply restate the diagnosis.
If ERISA does not apply to your plan, or you bought the policy independently, filing suit may be an option without an administrative appeal first. How to proceed depends on the policy terms and the governing law, which is a reason to have the policy reviewed before you choose a path.
What Evidence Can Help Challenge a Long-Term Disability Denial?
The evidence needed to challenge a long-term disability denial depends on why the insurer rejected the claim. A diagnosis alone is often not enough. The appeal needs to show how the illness or injury limits your ability to perform the duties your policy requires.
Medical records are an important part of that evidence, but they are not the only part. A disability lawyer can identify gaps in the insurer’s record and gather evidence that directly addresses the reasons for denial.
Helpful evidence includes:
- Treating Physician Support: A doctor’s explanation of your restrictions and limitations can connect the medical condition to the specific tasks you can no longer perform.
- Medical Testing: Imaging, laboratory results, cognitive testing, and other objective findings support symptoms and limitations that the insurer has questioned.
- Occupational Evidence: Job descriptions, employer records, and information about your actual duties help show what your occupation required before you became unable to work.
- Vocational Evidence: A vocational expert evaluates how your restrictions affect your ability to perform your occupation or other work when that issue is disputed.
- Statements and Other Records: Statements from people who have observed your limitations and records documenting how your condition affects daily activities can add context that does not always appear in medical charts.
Our long-term disability attorneys build a record that answers the denial point by point and shows why you meet the policy’s definition of disability.
How Can a Long-Term Disability Lawyer Challenge the Insurer’s Evidence?
Your long-term disability lawyer can challenge the medical, occupational, and other evidence the insurer used to deny your claim. That starts with obtaining the claim file and determining how the insurer reached its decision.
For example, an insurer may rely on a physician who reviewed your records without examining you. A lawyer can compare that physician’s conclusions with your treating doctors’ findings, test results, and documented restrictions and identify where the review leaves out or mischaracterizes important evidence.
Occupational disputes require the same close review. If the insurer argues that you could perform another version of your occupation, your lawyer can gather evidence about the duties you actually performed and compare them with the occupational definition in the policy.
Surveillance also needs context. A short video showing you driving, walking, or completing an errand does not necessarily establish that you can sustain the demands of full-time work. Your lawyer can compare what the surveillance actually shows with the limitations you reported and the requirements of your occupation.
In an ERISA claim, these responses generally need to become part of the administrative record during the appeal. Building that response before the record closes gives the insurer the evidence it must consider and preserves it for a court if litigation becomes necessary.
Why Work With Kantor & Kantor LLP
We are a law firm that handles insurance claims for policyholders. Long-term disability is a substantial part of that work, in cases governed by ERISA and in cases governed by state insurance law.
Clients come to us for reasons that include the following:
- Focus: Our firm focuses on insurance claims, rather than being one practice area among many.
- ERISA knowledge: We regularly work within the federal claims procedure, including administrative appeals.
- Litigation when needed: Our team prepares claims with the possibility of court in mind rather than assuming every case settles.
Long-Term Disability Lawyer FAQs
How long do I have to appeal a long-term disability denial?
For claims governed by ERISA, the plan must allow at least 180 days to appeal an adverse benefit determination, and the denial letter should state the deadline. Individual policies set their own appeal and suit limitation periods.
Can I submit new medical records after I file my appeal?
Under ERISA, the administrative record generally closes at the end of the appeal process, and a court will usually not consider material that was not submitted to the insurer. That is the single most common reason a strong case becomes difficult to win later. Everything you want a judge to see belongs in the appeal.
What if my benefits were approved and then stopped?
Insurers reassess claims and often terminate benefits after an internal review, a change in the policy’s definition of disability, or a limitation on certain conditions. If the insurer determines that you no longer qualify for benefits, that termination carries appeal rights like an initial denial.
Does it cost anything to have my denial reviewed?
Your initial consultation with Kantor & Kantor LLP is free. We will review your claim and can answer any questions you have.
What if my policy came through my employer?
An employer-sponsored plan is usually governed by ERISA, which changes the procedure, the evidence rules, and the remedies available. There are exceptions, including plans sponsored by the government and certain church employers. Determining which law applies is one of the first things to settle because it shapes everything that follows.
Talk With a Long-Term Disability Lawyer
A denial can be challenged, but what you do next matters. The evidence you gather, the deadlines you meet, and the arguments you make can shape both the appeal and any lawsuit that follows.
Kantor & Kantor LLP represents policyholders in long-term disability disputes. We can review the denial letter and the policy, explain what the language actually requires, and handle the appeal and any litigation that follows. Contact us today or call 818-886-2525 for your free consultation. We are people helping people.
A denial is not the final word. Contact Kantor & Kantor, LLP online or call us at 818-886-2525 to discuss how we may be able to help you secure the long-term disability benefits you deserve.
Attorney Glenn R. Kantor
Glenn Kantor is a founding partner of Kantor & Kantor LLP. As a young attorney, Glenn saw the injustice of wrongful insurance denials and created a law firm to represent individuals seeking to obtain their rightful benefits. Glenn is committed to ensure that clients receive the benefits they are entitled to under their insurance policies or group health plans. [Attorney Bio]